Understanding Church Membership in the Early 19th Century: A Cautionary Tale for Genealogists

A woman ponders at the crossroads which church she will attend from the four denominatons in the area.

Imagine a socially prominent woman of the early 19th-century South, standing at a crossroads, weighing the deeply personal and profoundly social implications of church membership. Sarah Haynsworth Gayle, wife of future Alabama Governor John Gayle, often found herself in just such a position—torn between the devout religious practices she held dear and the fear of surrendering her autonomy to a church’s authority. Her story offers a unique window into the complexities of faith and community during her time, and it challenges us to rethink how we interpret our ancestors’ religious lives.

Read more

Taming the AI Beast: Avoiding ChatGPT Hallucinations in Genohistory

A giant stone creature labeled "A.I." pours stones into the baskets of humans who are asking for answers. One has a sign saying, "Tell me what I want to hear." His basket fills with a majority of stones labeled, "bad data." He keeps the whole basket. The one on the right tells A.I. to use only vetted sources and the majority of her stones say "good data." She is manually tossing out any bad data that is put into her basket.

Genealogists and historians are diving headfirst into the exciting world of AI-assisted research, where tools like ChatGPT offer a wealth of possibilities for uncovering family and community stories. But how do you ensure you’re uncovering truths, not imaginative fabrications? AI hallucinations—those moments when ChatGPT confidently gives you false information—can mislead your research if you’re not vigilant. Here’s how to navigate AI’s challenges and harness its power for genohistory.

Read more

Boulder Demolition for Genohistorians: Uncovering Ancestral Trails

A huge boulder blocks a sojourners path.

If you have been doing ancestral research for some time, and taking it seriously, you know the glorious victory of tumbling a brick wall or two. You broke through to a piece of historical or genealogical knowledge that had eluded you. But some of us will eventually find our research path impeded by something bigger and much harder than a brick wall. What do you do when your path is blocked by a landslide of granite boulders ten times your height? The information you need is not just elusive. It’s gone.

Read more

Dental Terrors: How Sarah Made Me Smile

A woman faces her dread of getting a tooth pulled in a circa-1830s barbershop, where the barber pulls teeth for $2.

I left my dentist’s office today with a smile on my face and a bounce in my step. This, after having a crown replaced. Was it free, you wonder? Not even close. Was it painless then, you ask? There was pain. But something beautiful happened, as needles and drills entered my mouth: I remembered Sarah Gayle and her dental terrors.

Read more

Born Here, Died There: The Life between Bookends

Three people described in the article are shown in a painting-style conversion of an original photograph.

My 2nd-great-grandfather Jacob Dennis Mayberry, widowed in 1917, desired a fresh start. In 1919, he purchased a 440-acre farm in Chilton County, Alabama, 24 miles northeast of his former residence in Bibb County. He built a large and rambling house around the old cabin that stood there. His daughter, Clara, her husband, Otha Payne, and their baby, Clara Thomas Payne (my grandmother), and his unmarried daughter Mary Thomas Mayberry moved with him to the new place. And on this property, they all lived out the rest of their lives, though you would not know that by a basic family tree.

Read more

Getting Rid of Riley: Answers in Community-wide Research

An enslaved man stands in a jail cell with a wealthy planter standing outside the cell. A plantation house can be seen in the distance.

The real magic of genealogy manifests outside the traditional box—beyond the standard family tree data. Let me tell you about a man named Riley and the odd place I found the next piece of his story.

Read more